Skip to main content
Find your Fire Island RentalRentBuy a Fire Island PropertyBuy
search properties
Search by Property ID#
search properties

Search Results

Rented for 2023 Fair Harbor summer rental # 16
4 2 Bay Front

FAIR HARBOR - On the Bay Front #162

Call per week
Stunning Bay Views from the living, dining and kitchen areas of this vacation home.
learn more
6/30-8/14;Two wk min Fair Harbor Summer Home # 10
3 1 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Easy, Breezy Cottage #10

Call per week
This Fair Harbor beach cottage is just steps from the ocean yet convenient to everything in Fair Harbor
learn more
July 24 - August 7 Fair Harbor Vacation Rental with Two bedrooms
2 2 Bay-Side

FAIR HARBOR Charm #109

Call per week
Located on one of the loveliest bay side Fair Harbor walks, this cottage has some highly desirable amenities. 
learn more
Rented for 2023 Summer home for rent in Fair Harbor Fire Island
3 1.5 Bay-Side

Comfort, Peace and Quiet Assured #107

Call per week
This Fire Island bay side home has a number of features which make it a unique offering.
learn more
7/28 - 8/7 & 8/21 - 9/4 Fair Harbor Fire Island Summer Rental
3 1.5 Bay-Side

FAIR HARBOR with BAY VIEWS #747

Call per week
Summer time, summer time, summer time....this Fair Harbor beach house is a wonderful vacation spot.
learn more
Rented for 2023 Contemporary Styling in Fair Harbor
4 2.5

A Summer Idyll in Fair Harbor #38

$7k per week
Fair Harbor and the Living is Easy
learn more
July 1 - 14 Traditional Styling in this Fire Island rental
4 2 Bay-Side

FAIR HARBOR Convenience Comfort #35

Call per week
Four bedroom house with spacious deck and beautiful yard area.
learn more
July 17 - 31 Fair Harbor Beach Cottage 133 Ready for Summer
3 2 Bay-Side

Fair Harbor Summer Ready #133

$4,500 per week
Fair Harbor Beach Cottage Ready for Summer. Convenient Location with Spacious Decks
learn more
7/28 -8/11; 8/25-9/8 Fair Harbor Beach House for Rent
3 1.5 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Steps to the Beach #116

Call per week
This Fair Harbor Beach House, just steps to the beach with three bedrooms
learn more
Rented for 2023 Fair Harbor Ocean Views Summer Rental # 48
4 2 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Ocean Views #48

Call per week
Enjoy ocean breezes and ocean views from every room in this charming Fair Harbor Fire Island beach house.
learn more
Rented for 2023 Bay Front Living in Fair Harbor Fire Island
4 2 Bay Front

FAIR HARBOR Beautiful on the Bay #17

Call per week
Enjoy stunning sunset views from this spacious, family friendly
learn more
Rented for 2023 Fire island
4 1.5 Ocean-Side

FAIR HARBOR Ocean Side Cottage #105

Call per week
This four bedroom Fair Harbor summer rental is located on a beach block
learn more